Skip to content
Insight

To opt out or not? Weighing Google’s new AI Search toggle for UK businesses

Google now lets you pull your website out of AI Overviews and AI Mode using a toggle in Google Search Console, and your normal rankings stay exactly where they are. The control will not be used as a ranking signal, and it is being tested with UK sites first.

UK businesses can now ask Google to keep their content out of its AI search features, because the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) required Google to offer that control. Whether you should use it is a separate question, and it is easy to decide before the data is in.

What the CMA required

The CMA designated Google with strategic market status in general search in October 2025, under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024. On 3 June 2026 it imposed its first conduct requirement on Google, covering publisher controls. ‘Publisher’ here means any party that makes content available on the web, so it applies to business websites as well as media sites.

Under the requirement, Google must give publishers controls to withhold their content from:

  • Training Google’s generative AI models used within and outside search
  • Grounding answers in its AI features inside search, such as AI Overviews and AI Mode
  • Grounding answers in AI features outside search; the CMA gives the Gemini assistant as an example

The controls for grounding inside search must work at directory and page level. Google must not penalise sites that use them, for example by ranking them lower in the rest of Search. It must also attribute publisher content in AI search features with a clear way to reach the source, and provide transparency metrics, including impressions, clicks and click through rate for features such as AI Overviews and AI Mode.

Google has until 3 December 2026 to comply, with a further three months to roll out a page level control. It began testing a Search Console toggle with a subset of UK sites in June 2026.

What the toggle does

The setting sits in Google Search Console. Sites that opt out keep their place in standard search results, and Google has said the setting is not a ranking signal. Opting out also means no traffic and no impressions from the AI features it covers. Because Google is rolling the controls out in stages, check Google’s Search Console documentation for exactly which features the toggle covers on the day you decide.

If your content is currently cited in AI Overviews, opting out switches that visibility off completely. For some brands that is a relief. For others it is a loss of reach that only shows up months later.

Check whether you are cited before you decide

Google’s AI reports in Search Console launched with impressions only. The CMA requires clicks and click through rate as well, but until those arrive you are deciding with half the numbers. Fill the gap with your own evidence. Take the questions that bring you enquiries, run them in Google, and record for each AI Overview whether it:

  • Cites a page on your site as a source
  • Recommends your brand by name without citing your site
  • Leaves you out, and which sources and competitors it uses instead

Answers change between checks, so repeat this over a few weeks. If you are already absent from the answers that matter, the toggle changes little for you in AI features. If you are cited on questions that drive enquiries, opting out removes that. Our guide to generative engine optimisation for UK brands covers the tracking method.

The case for staying in

Being cited can earn clicks as well as cost them, particularly on question led searches where your page is the one the answer quotes. If you have already put work into being a cited source, opting out throws that away.

FactorStay in AI SearchOpt out
ReachAI Overviews and AI Mode answers, as well as standard resultsStandard search and Discover only
Traffic from AI featuresPossible, if you are citedNone
Control over how content appearsLimitedFull
Reporting in Search ConsoleImpressions at launch; clicks required by the CMANot applicable
Best suited toBrands chasing awarenessBrands protecting detailed content

The case for opting out

Some businesses lose more than they gain. A 2025 Ahrefs analysis found click through rates for top ranking pages fell by around a third when an AI Overview appeared above them. If you sell a considered service and your detailed guides are being summarised above the link, you may prefer the click to the citation.

Picture an accountancy firm whose pricing explainer ranks first while an AI Overview answers the question above it, and enquiries from that page dip each week. For that firm, opting out that section and measuring the change is a reasonable experiment. For a retailer that wants its brand named in as many answers as possible, it rarely is.

How to decide without guessing

  1. List the pages that appear in AI features, from Search Console and your own checks
  2. Note the enquiries and revenue each of those pages drives
  3. Record whether the AI answers for those queries cite you, name you or leave you out
  4. If you test the toggle, start with one directory once directory level controls are available, and compare enquiries before and after
  5. Keep the decision under review as Google adds clicks and click through rate to the reports

If AI features are taking clicks on a few high value terms, paid search can cover those terms while you test.

Fair ranking rules: what to document if your visibility drops

On 17 June 2026 the CMA imposed a second conduct requirement on Google, on fair ranking. Google must rank organic results, including inside AI Overviews, using objective and non discriminatory criteria. Sponsored results are out of scope. Google has six months to implement it.

Keep expectations measured. The CMA has said it will judge compliance mainly by looking at Google’s ranking processes and policies rather than individual ranking outcomes, and new features, including AI features, can be exempt from parts of the requirement for up to six months while Google tests them. What businesses gain is a route to raise concerns, and that route depends on evidence.

Record these before you need them:

  • Baseline rankings, clicks and traffic, with dates, from Search Console and GA4
  • Affected queries and landing pages, from the Search Console performance report
  • Result type: organic, AI Overview or sponsored, with dated screenshots, since only organic results and AI Overviews are covered
  • Timeline against confirmed Google updates, to separate an algorithm change from anything else
  • Your own site changes, from deploy logs and CMS history
  • Lead and revenue impact in £, from GA4 and your CRM

Rule out the causes you control first. A technical SEO triage and a check of recent template, plugin and CMS changes (see our SEO specs for developers) explain many drops that look like Google’s doing.

Frequently asked questions

Can you stop your website appearing in Google AI Overviews?

Yes. The Search Console control lets sites withhold content from Google’s AI search features while staying in standard search results. Check Google’s documentation for the features it covers as the rollout continues.

Will opting out of AI Search hurt your Google ranking?

Google has said the setting is not a ranking signal, and the CMA requirement bars Google from penalising sites that use the controls.

What is the difference between AI Overviews and AI Mode?

AI Overviews are the AI summaries shown above the results. AI Mode is a separate conversational search experience where you can ask follow up questions.

Does the fair ranking rule cover ads?

No. It covers organic results and AI Overviews, not sponsored results.

Is the opt out available to every UK business yet?

Not yet. Google is still testing it with a subset of UK sites.

If you want to see which of your priority questions return AI answers that cite you, talk to Totally.Digital.